Pressing the grapes…
🏆 Best Bakery · Staten IslandThe best Bakery
The best Bakery
in Staten Island, NY.
Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering in Mariners Harbor takes the top spot , with Crumbl in West Brighton right behind it. Every bakery place we track in Staten Island, NY, measured the same way and ordered best first.
1Rank
Poppy Seed Bagels & CateringTop 10%
Mariners Harbor · Bagels · $
#1 Bagels in Staten IslandTop 10% in Richmond County, on 522 ratings.
95Sweet Score522 ratings
2Rank
CrumblTop 10%
West Brighton · Dessert
#2 Dessert in Staten IslandTop 10% in Richmond County, on 1,174 ratings.
94Sweet Score1,174 ratings
3Rank
Georgian Bread HouseTop 10%
Great Kills · Bakery · $$
#1 Bakery in Staten IslandTop 10% in Richmond County, on 127 ratings.
94Sweet Score127 ratings
4Rank
Paris BaguetteTop 10%
Mid Island · Coffee
Top 10% in Richmond County, on 337 ratings.
93Sweet Score337 ratings
5Rank
Crumbl – Cookies & DessertsTop 10%
Charleston · Dessert
#2 in CharlestonTop 10% in Richmond County, on 1,144 ratings.
92Sweet Score1,144 ratings
6Rank
Brooklyn Bagels and CafeTop 10%
Bloomfield · Bagels · $
#1 in BloomfieldTop 10% in Richmond County, on 928 ratings.
91Sweet Score928 ratings
7Rank
Melone & Sons IncTop 10%
Port Richmond · Bakery · $
#2 Bakery in Staten IslandTop 10% in Richmond County, on 88 ratings.
91Sweet Score88 ratings
8Rank
Bagels N' BunsTop 10%
Mid Island · Bagels · $
Top 10% in Richmond County, on 537 ratings.
90Sweet Score537 ratings
9Rank
Problem bakerTop 10%
Randall Manor · Coffee
Top 10% in Richmond County, on 226 ratings.
90Sweet Score226 ratings
10Rank
Mark's Bake ShoppeTop 25%
Lighthouse Hill · Bakery · $$
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 308 ratings behind it.
88Sweet Score308 ratings
11Rank
Cookie JarTop 25%
Castleton Corners · Coffee
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 539 ratings behind it.
87Sweet Score539 ratings
12Rank
Plaza Bagels and DeliTop 25%
New Dorp · Bagels · $
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 175 ratings behind it.
87Sweet Score175 ratings
13Rank
Jerusalem SweetsTop 25%
Arrochar · Bakery
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 58 ratings behind it.
86Sweet Score58 ratings
14Rank
CakeChefTop 25%
Castleton Corners · Bakery · $$
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 566 ratings behind it.
83Sweet Score566 ratings
15Rank
Annadale BakeryTop 25%
Arden Heights · Dessert · $$
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 507 ratings behind it.
83Sweet Score507 ratings
16Rank
Mikey BagelsTop 25%
Tottenville · Bagels · $
#2 in TottenvilleUpper quarter of Richmond County — 224 ratings behind it.
83Sweet Score224 ratings
17Rank
Holtermann's BakeryTop 25%
Staten Island · Bakery · $$
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 555 ratings behind it.
81Sweet Score555 ratings
18Rank
Bagels R UsTop 25%
Eltingville · Bagels · $
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 899 ratings behind it.
80Sweet Score899 ratings
19Rank
Forest BagelsTop 25%
Castleton Corners · Bagels · $
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 579 ratings behind it.
79Sweet Score579 ratings
20Rank
Buono BakeryTop 25%
Concord · Bakery · $$
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 323 ratings behind it.
78Sweet Score323 ratings
21Rank
Yallah Habibi DessertsTop 25%
Castleton Corners · Dessert
Upper quarter of Richmond County — 194 ratings behind it.
78Sweet Score194 ratings
22Rank
Bagels By The Bay🥯Local favorite
Rosebank · Bagels · $
Rated above the typical place in Richmond County.
77Sweet Score282 ratings
23Rank
Donut WorldLocal favorite
Manor Heights · Dessert · $
Rated above the typical place in Richmond County.
76Sweet Score410 ratings
24Rank
Moretti BakeryLocal favorite
West Brighton · Bakery · $$
Rated above the typical place in Richmond County.
76Sweet Score299 ratings
Know somewhere we’re missing?
Put it on the map. The most-requested places go to the front of the queue — anonymous visit, on our dime.
Rankings order by the Sweet Score; ties break by the regulars’ score. Promoted placements never appear in rankings — they’re labeled and live elsewhere. How ranking works →