sour grapes ✦The best, ranked & rated.
Join free
🍴 Dish · Key Lime Pie · Suffolk

Best places for
key lime pie in Suffolk County, NY.

13 places in Suffolk County, NY get the key lime pie mentioned by name in their reviews. 6 of them have earned a Sweet Score. Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery is first here (84), RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum Bar second (83). Expect $$, $15–30 β€” that covers 69% of the places here. Places here also get named for burger, calamari and lobster roll.

6 scored Β· 13 mention it Β· 10 towns

EverywhereLong IslandNassauSuffolkQueensBrooklynManhattanThe BronxStaten Island← All dishes
Sort
Filter🍽️ Key Lime Pieβœ•
13 places
1Rank

Millie's Mimosa House & EateryTop 25%Underrated

Babylon Β· Breakfast & Brunch Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forlatte Β· french toast Β· key lime pie

Upper quarter of Suffolk County β€” 184 ratings behind it.

84Sweet Score184 ratings
2Rank

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarTop 25%

Hampton Bays Β· Caribbean Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie Β· burger Β· jerk chicken

Upper quarter of Suffolk County β€” 1,542 ratings behind it.

83Sweet Score1,542 ratings
3Rank

Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and BarTop 25%

Riverhead Β· Bar & Grill Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forcalamari Β· chicken tenders Β· key lime pie

Upper quarter of Suffolk County β€” 133 ratings behind it.

78Sweet Score133 ratings
4Rank

Chowder BarLocal favorite

Bay Shore Β· Seafood Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forclam chowder Β· key lime pie Β· fish sandwich

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

72Sweet Score512 ratings
5Rank

LUNCH Lobster Roll SouthamptonLocal favorite

Southampton Β· Seafood Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forcalamari Β· clam chowder Β· fish and chips

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

71Sweet Score511 ratings
6Rank

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarLocal favorite

Patchogue Β· Caribbean Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forempanadas Β· burger Β· chicken sandwich

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

62Sweet Score1,703 ratings
β€”

THE JAMES

Babylon Β· American Β· $$$$ Β· $60+/person
Known forfilet mignon Β· eggs benedict Β· key lime pie

β€”No score yet440 ratings
β€”

The Frisky Oyster

Greenport Β· Seafood Β· $$$$ Β· $60+/person
Known forkey lime pie Β· truffle fries Β· burrata

β€”No score yet441 ratings
β€”

The Ritz Cafe

Northport Β· American Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie Β· burger

β€”No score yet263 ratings
β€”

The Old Mill Inn

Mattituck Β· American Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie Β· oysters

β€”No score yet125 ratings
β€”

Westlake Fish House

Montauk Β· Seafood Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forcalamari Β· fish tacos Β· key lime pie

β€”No score yet281 ratings
β€”

Symi Restaurant

Northport Β· Greek Β· $$$ Β· $30–60/person
Known forbaklava Β· calamari Β· cheesecake

β€”No score yet222 ratings
β€”

The Shipyard Restaurant & Bar

Greenport Β· American Β· $$$ Β· $30–60/person
Known forceviche Β· shrimp cocktail Β· chicken tenders

β€”No score yet96 ratings

That’s all 13 of them ✦

Straight answers πŸ’¬

Key Lime Pie in Suffolk County, NY, briefly

What is the best key lime pie in Suffolk County, NY?

Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery currently ranks first with a Sweet Score of 84, built on 184 ratings. The list re-sorts itself as ratings move, so first place is not permanent.

How many places in Suffolk County, NY are known for their key lime pie?

We track 13. 6 of them have earned a Sweet Score, which means they rated above the median for their county and category. The rest are listed with their address, hours and what people order β€” just without a number.

How much do places serving key lime pie cost in Suffolk County, NY?

The commonest price band on this list is $$ β€” $15–30 β€” covering 69% of the places we track here.

How is this list ordered?

By the Sweet Score, a 4–96 rating built from where a place ranks against others in its own county and its own category. 50 is the median, 78 is the top quarter, 90 is the top 10%. A place below the median is still listed β€” it just doesn't carry a number, because we only publish a score when it's good news.

Dishes come from what reviewers wrote, matched against a fixed list so nothing is invented. The ranking is of the restaurants, not of the dish itself. How ranking works β†’