sour grapes ✦The best, ranked & rated.
🍴 Dish · Key Lime Pie · Long Island

Best places for
key lime pie in Long Island, NY.

We track 18 places in Long Island, NY where the key lime pie comes up unprompted. 9 sit above the bar. bartaco is first here (94), Toto's second (91). 2 of them clear 90, which is the top 10% of the county. Expect $$, $15–30 — that covers 67% of the places here.

9 scored · 18 mention it · 15 towns

EverywhereLong IslandNassauSuffolkQueensBrooklynManhattanThe BronxStaten Island← All dishes
Sort
Filter🍽️ Key Lime Pie✕
18 places
1Rank

bartacoTop 10%

Garden City · Mexican · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forfish tacos · guacamole · churros

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 927 ratings.

94Sweet Score927 ratings
2Rank

Toto'sTop 10%Underrated

Wantagh · Steakhouse · $$$ · $30–60/person
Known forkey lime pie · bolognese · affogato#2 Steakhouse in Nassau

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 178 ratings.

91Sweet Score178 ratings
3Rank

CopperhillTop 25%

Williston Park · American · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie

Upper quarter of Nassau County — 837 ratings behind it.

86Sweet Score837 ratings
4Rank

Millie's Mimosa House & EateryTop 25%Underrated

Babylon · Breakfast & Brunch · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forlatte · french toast · key lime pie

Upper quarter of Suffolk County — 184 ratings behind it.

84Sweet Score184 ratings
5Rank

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarTop 25%

Hampton Bays · Caribbean · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie · burger · jerk chicken

Upper quarter of Suffolk County — 1,542 ratings behind it.

83Sweet Score1,542 ratings
6Rank

Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and BarTop 25%

Riverhead · Bar & Grill · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forcalamari · chicken tenders · key lime pie

Upper quarter of Suffolk County — 133 ratings behind it.

78Sweet Score133 ratings
7Rank

Chowder BarLocal favorite

Bay Shore · Seafood · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forclam chowder · key lime pie · fish sandwich

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

72Sweet Score512 ratings
8Rank

LUNCH Lobster Roll SouthamptonLocal favorite

Southampton · Seafood · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forcalamari · clam chowder · fish and chips

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

71Sweet Score511 ratings
9Rank

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarLocal favorite

Patchogue · Caribbean · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forempanadas · burger · chicken sandwich

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

62Sweet Score1,703 ratings
—

THE JAMES

Babylon · American · $$$$ · $60+/person
Known forfilet mignon · eggs benedict · key lime pie

—No score yet440 ratings
—

The Frisky Oyster

Greenport · Seafood · $$$$ · $60+/person
Known forkey lime pie · truffle fries · burrata

—No score yet441 ratings
—

The Ritz Cafe

Northport · American · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie · burger

—No score yet263 ratings
—

PRIME1024

Roslyn · Steakhouse · $$$$ · $60+/person
Known forkey lime pie · burrata · lamb chops

—No score yet749 ratings
—

The Old Mill Inn

Mattituck · American · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie · oysters

—No score yet125 ratings
—

Westlake Fish House

Montauk · Seafood · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forcalamari · fish tacos · key lime pie

—No score yet281 ratings
—

Symi Restaurant

Northport · Greek · $$$ · $30–60/person
Known forbaklava · calamari · cheesecake

—No score yet222 ratings
—

The Shipyard Restaurant & Bar

Greenport · American · $$$ · $30–60/person
Known forceviche · shrimp cocktail · chicken tenders

—No score yet96 ratings
—

Alibi Lounge

Farmingdale · Bar & Grill · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forkey lime pie · hummus

—No score yet128 ratings

That’s all 18 of them ✦

Straight answers 💬

Key Lime Pie in Long Island, NY, briefly

What is the best key lime pie in Long Island, NY?

bartaco currently ranks first with a Sweet Score of 94, built on 927 ratings. The list re-sorts itself as ratings move, so first place is not permanent.

How many places in Long Island, NY are known for their key lime pie?

We track 18. 9 of them have earned a Sweet Score, which means they rated above the median for their county and category. The rest are listed with their address, hours and what people order — just without a number.

How much do places serving key lime pie cost in Long Island, NY?

The commonest price band on this list is $$ — $15–30 — covering 67% of the places we track here.

How is this list ordered?

By the Sweet Score, a 4–96 rating built from where a place ranks against others in its own county and its own category. 50 is the median, 78 is the top quarter, 90 is the top 10%. A place below the median is still listed — it just doesn't carry a number, because we only publish a score when it's good news.

Dishes come from what reviewers wrote, matched against a fixed list so nothing is invented. The ranking is of the restaurants, not of the dish itself. How ranking works →