Best places for
key lime pie in Long Island, NY.
We track 18 places in Long Island, NY where the key lime pie comes up unprompted. 9 sit above the bar. bartaco is first here (94), Toto's second (91). 2 of them clear 90, which is the top 10% of the county. Expect $$, $15–30 — that covers 67% of the places here.
- Typical place carries 281 ratings
- 7 deliver
- 14 take reservations
- 14 have outdoor seating
- 3 open for breakfast
- 2 flagged underrated — good, and barely found
bartacoTop 10%
Top 10% in Nassau County, on 927 ratings.
Toto'sTop 10%Underrated
Top 10% in Nassau County, on 178 ratings.
CopperhillTop 25%
Upper quarter of Nassau County — 837 ratings behind it.
Millie's Mimosa House & EateryTop 25%Underrated
Upper quarter of Suffolk County — 184 ratings behind it.
RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarTop 25%
Upper quarter of Suffolk County — 1,542 ratings behind it.
Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and BarTop 25%
Upper quarter of Suffolk County — 133 ratings behind it.
Chowder BarLocal favorite
Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.
LUNCH Lobster Roll SouthamptonLocal favorite
Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.
RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarLocal favorite
Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.
THE JAMES
The Frisky Oyster
The Ritz Cafe
PRIME1024
The Old Mill Inn
Westlake Fish House
Symi Restaurant
The Shipyard Restaurant & Bar
Alibi Lounge
That’s all 18 of them ✦
Key Lime Pie in Long Island, NY, briefly
What is the best key lime pie in Long Island, NY?
bartaco currently ranks first with a Sweet Score of 94, built on 927 ratings. The list re-sorts itself as ratings move, so first place is not permanent.
How many places in Long Island, NY are known for their key lime pie?
We track 18. 9 of them have earned a Sweet Score, which means they rated above the median for their county and category. The rest are listed with their address, hours and what people order — just without a number.
How much do places serving key lime pie cost in Long Island, NY?
The commonest price band on this list is $$ — $15–30 — covering 67% of the places we track here.
How is this list ordered?
By the Sweet Score, a 4–96 rating built from where a place ranks against others in its own county and its own category. 50 is the median, 78 is the top quarter, 90 is the top 10%. A place below the median is still listed — it just doesn't carry a number, because we only publish a score when it's good news.
Dishes come from what reviewers wrote, matched against a fixed list so nothing is invented. The ranking is of the restaurants, not of the dish itself. How ranking works →