sour grapes ✦The best, ranked & rated.
❓ Frequently asked · 78 answers

Questions, answered flat.

The questions we get most about Sour Grapes — how the Sweet Score is built, what a badge is worth, who the Tasters are, and what happens when something on a listing is wrong. No accordions to click through. It’s all just here.

Scores can't be bought. Only earned.

Section 1 of 13

Finding somewhere to eat

The part most people came for. Four doors into the same set of listings, depending on how you already think about where to eat.

I just want somewhere good. Where do I start?

Start with your town if you know roughly where you're going, or search if you know roughly what you want. Both land you in the same place: a list ordered best first, on one scale, with the Sweet Score next to every place that has earned one.

What is the difference between Reviews, Rankings and Browse?

Reviews is everything we track in one long ranked list you can sort and filter. Rankings splits that same board by category — best pizza, best sushi, best steakhouse. Browse cuts it by what you need tonight: outdoor seating, open late, takes reservations, good with kids. Same listings, three ways in.

Can I search by dish instead of by restaurant?

Yes, and it's the nicest way to use the site. Dishes lists every dish reviewers have named, each one a ranked page of the places serving it. We never invent a menu item — a dish only gets a page because somebody wrote about eating it.

How do I find places in my town specifically?

The town index has every village across Long Island and all five boroughs of New York City, each with its own ranked page. We know Massapequa is not Massapequa Park, and we know which one you meant.

What do the dollar signs mean?

Roughly what one person spends: $ is under $15, $$ is $15–30, $$$ is $30–60, $$$$ is $60+. It's a band, not a promise — you can always beat it or blow past it depending on what you order.

Why does a place with no score still show up in the list?

Because a listing without a grade is still useful. Address, hours, category, photos, whatever the tasters have added — all of that is there. What's missing is the number, and that's deliberate: we publish a score only once a place has clearly earned one. Everything else on the page is a fact, and facts don't need a bar to clear.

↑ Back to top

Section 2 of 13

The Sweet Score

One headline number out of 100, built from where a place stands against every other place in its county. The whole method is public on the methodology page; this is the short version.

What is the Sweet Score?

A rating out of 100, built out of a rank. That distinction is the entire point: a star average tells you how a place felt to whoever rated it, while the Sweet Score tells you where it sits against every other place we track. 90 means only one in ten sit above it, and that is a claim with arithmetic behind it.

Why is 50 the middle?

Because it is, by construction. 50 is the median of every county, so a place scoring above it is genuinely above average rather than above some line we liked the look of. It is also the only threshold on this site that can be defended without hand-waving, which is why a number, a badge and a rank all switch on at exactly that point.

Where does the number come from?

One of three places, in a fixed order. It is ours when we have been ourselves — anonymous visits, every check paid out of our own pocket. Failing that it is the Tasters', once enough of them have written the place up. Failing that it is built from the ratings the place already carries, weighted for how much evidence stands behind them. The order never changes and the page always tells you which one you're looking at. The full method is here.

Why does the scale stop at 96?

Because nothing is perfect and nothing is worthless. The scale is built to land between 4 and 96, so no restaurant is ever called flawless and none is ever handed a zero. A 96 is the top of the board, and it still means somebody could have a better Tuesday.

Why do some listings have no score at all?

Two reasons. Either the place hasn't cleared 50 — in which case we publish the facts and skip the grade — or there simply isn't enough evidence yet. Under 25 ratings, with nobody having been and no tasters filed, we don't place it at all. Too thin to be fair in either direction.

Can a restaurant pay to move its score?

No, and not in the careful lawyerly sense of no. There is no internal process by which money reaches a score, because we never built one. Advertising is labeled, lives outside the rankings, and our reviewers don't know who advertises. Scores can't be bought. Only earned.

Do scores change?

Yes, in both directions. Ranked places go back into the rotation on a fixed schedule — the same schedule for the ones we loved and the ones paying us for a banner — and nobody can request, rush or delay a return trip. Chefs change, kitchens find their feet, standards move. A score is a snapshot with a date printed on it.

Why not publish the exact formula?

Everything we control is spelled out: the same scale for every place, the 7 questions the tasters answer, the thresholds on this page. The one part we keep back is the precise weighting used where a score leans on ratings a place already carries — publishing that would be an instruction manual for inflating one, and the people most motivated to read it are exactly the people it would help least honestly.

↑ Back to top

Section 3 of 13

Badges, ranks & Underrated

Four things we can say about a restaurant. All four are good, because we don't publish the other kind.

What do the badges mean?

Local favorite is 50 and up — better regarded than the typical place we track. Top 25% starts at 78. Top 10% starts at 90. And 💎 Underrated is its own thing, explained two questions down. Badges are free, they can't be bought, and they ride on the Sweet Score alone. The badge key in full →

What does Top 10% actually mean?

Exactly what it says. A score of 90 puts a place above nine in ten places in its own county, not above nine in ten of a shortlist we hand-picked. It is the reason the badge is worth wearing.

My rating only moved a tenth of a star. Why did my score move so much?

Because a tenth of a star is a bigger difference than it looks. Ratings for real restaurants sit almost entirely between 4.0 and 4.7, so that narrow band contains most of the field — and a tenth of a star moves a place past a lot of other places. In a typical county, one tenth is worth roughly twelve points of Sweet Score around the middle of the scale. Nothing has gone wrong; the score is doing what a ranking does with a tightly packed field.

Two places I know are very different have almost the same score. How?

Because they are close on the evidence, not because the score is guessing. Ratings for real, operating restaurants sit in a narrow band, so most of the separation on this site comes from the other two things the score reads: how much evidence stands behind a place, and how it compares inside its own category. That is why two places sharing a star rating still spread across roughly 26 points here. Nothing is ranked at all below 25 ratings, and no place is ever called bad — below the median we publish the facts and no number. If a listing looks wrong to you, tell us — we would rather hear it.

Can I see the arithmetic behind my listing's score?

Yes. Tap the number on any listing and the panel shows where the place sits in its town, its category and its county. The method page sets out every step: the shrinkage toward the county average, the 70/30 blend of county and category position, and the 4-to-96 scale. Nothing about it is discretionary, and no part of it can be bought — advertising is labelled, sits outside the rankings, and has no route to a score.

What is the 💎 Underrated badge?

The best kind of listing on this site: a place rated 78 or higher that fewer than 40% as many people have found compared with a typical place in its own category. Rates beautifully, barely anyone knows. It is the only comparison we publish, and it only ever points one way.

Why does a place have a position but no score?

Because a position is a fact and a grade is a judgement. Every listing gets its ordinal spot in the lists it belongs to — #41 of 73 is simply where it sits, and nobody is insulted by arithmetic. The 0–100 number reads as a grade, so it only appears once a place is above average.

Is there a badge for the bottom of the scale?

No. There is no bad list here, no wall of shame, no red tier, no adjective for a place that hasn't cleared the bar. Sorting the sweet from the sour is the whole job — we just never show you the sour part. Why we only publish good news →

What are the three numbers on a listing page?

In this order, every time: the Sweet Score (the headline), the Tasters' score (computed from people who have eaten there), and would you go back (the share of members who said yes). Same order on every page, every card, every email, so nothing can be reordered into looking better than it is. When they disagree, that is usually the most interesting thing on the page, and we leave it visible.

Does 'would you go back?' feed the Sweet Score?

No. It's one question put to every member, one vote per person per place, and you see the result only after you've cast yours. It's a recommendation, not a rating, and it sits next to the number rather than inside it. Write a take and your vote is recorded automatically from your going-back answer — no second tap, and the take and the vote can never disagree.

↑ Back to top

Section 4 of 13

The Tasters & writing a review

The half of this site we don't write. Real people, real meals, a short list of pointed questions, and a score nobody hand-picks.

Who are the Tasters?

Members who write a place up. Everybody knows three or four places worth the drive; the Tasters are the ones who bothered to write them down. Their takes publish under their own display name, and their answers roll up into the tasters' score. Meet the Tasters →

How do I join?

Anyone can. It's free, it stays free, and the only qualification is that you ate the food yourself. Sign up, or log in if you're already here.

What does writing a take involve?

7 forced-choice statements about one meal you ate yourself — the food, the people, the room, the price, whether it would hold up on a normal night, and whether you were still thinking about it — agree or disagree, strongly or not. Then one last question: would you go back? About ninety seconds. There is no neutral option, because "it was fine" never helped anybody pick a Friday night.

Why a questionnaire instead of a text box?

A blank box asks you to be a writer. Specific statements just ask you what happened, which is the part a stranger can use. Your answers get assembled into a short write-up in the house voice, with your own best lines quoted as you said them.

Do I see the write-up before it publishes?

Nothing publishes until you approve every word. Not a paraphrase you half-recognise — every word. Change anything, or bin the whole thing, right up to the second you hit approve. It goes out under your display name, not "a verified diner".

When does a tasters' score appear?

As soon as one take exists. It used to wait for three, which meant the first person to write a place up watched their work produce nothing — a strange reward for going somewhere nobody had been. The listing prints how many takes the score stands on, so one is never dressed up as twenty. It is computed from everyone's answers on one shared scale, no single person sets it, and tasters never see our number before they answer.

Can I write up a place I own or work for?

No — and that includes a place you're related to the owner of, or run a rival to, and takes written on somebody else's behalf. Disclose a connection and we'll sort it out; hide one and it ends the account. The house rules →

Can I change or delete my take later?

Delete: any time, from My takes in your account, on the spot, no request to file. Edit: any time too, from the same place — headline, write-up, visit date, your answers and your verdict. An edited take carries an edited date wherever it appears, so a revision is never mistaken for what you wrote the day it went up. What you can't do is delete somebody else's, and we don't accept deletion requests routed through a third party claiming to speak for the author.

What's the score stamped on my take?

That's your Taster Score — one taster, one meal, 0 to 100, computed from your own answers and nothing else. It belongs to your take, not to the restaurant. The listing-wide Tasters' score is a different number: it pools every take on the place, and the listing says how many that is.

↑ Back to top

Section 5 of 13

Photos

What the food really looks like, from the listings themselves and from members who were there.

Where do the photos come from?

Mostly from the listings themselves. On top of that, members can add their own from a meal they ate — which are usually the more honest ones, because nobody styled the sandwich first.

Can I add my own?

Yes, once you're signed in. Photos and short clips, a few at a time, with an optional caption. The uploader tells you the size limits before it accepts anything. Join free if you haven't yet.

What happens after I upload one?

It goes into a moderation queue and waits for a person. That's a deliberate speed bump: it keeps staff photos, menus of other restaurants and the occasional act of vandalism off a page that somebody's livelihood is attached to.

What shouldn't I upload?

Anything with staff in it, anything that identifies a customer who didn't ask to be identified, anything you didn't take, and anything that isn't the restaurant. The same rules that govern a take govern a photo. House rules →

Do photos affect a score?

Not at all. A great photo of a mediocre plate is still a mediocre plate, and a badly lit one of something wonderful is still wonderful. Photos help you decide; they don't feed the arithmetic.

↑ Back to top

Section 6 of 13

Where we cover

Nassau, Suffolk, Queens, Kings, New York, Bronx, Richmond first, then the rest of New York. Density before pins on a map.

Where do you cover right now?

Long Island and all five boroughs of New York City, down to the village. Every town has its own ranked page, and we're expanding through New York from there.

Are you coming to my area?

Eventually, area by area. A new one opens when we can cover it properly — not when the map would look better with more pins on it. If you want to nudge us toward yours, tell us where you are.

Why start with one region instead of going national?

Because a discovery site is only useful when the coverage is dense enough that your specific block is on it. Going nationwide on day one is how you end up with three listings a town and no reason to come back.

Is it only restaurants?

For now. Restaurants are where we started; they aren't where this stops. The scoring is deliberately written without any reference to food, so the same machinery works the day we point it at something else.

A place near me is missing. Can I add it?

Please do. Add a restaurant takes about twenty seconds and it's on the map for good — searchable, rankable, open to everyone. Then be the first to write it up.

↑ Back to top

Section 7 of 13

For restaurant owners

Two things are true at once: this is a business, and the number next to your name is untouchable.

How do I claim my listing, and what does it cost?

Nothing, now or ever. The fastest route: your own listing page has a “Own this place? Claim your listing” button that opens the contact form with the topic and restaurant already filled in — a business email on your restaurant's own domain is the quickest way to verify. Claiming lets you fix your details, add photos and reply to takes in public. It does not move your score, change where you rank, or put you in front of anybody who wasn't already looking.

My hours or address are wrong. How do I fix them?

Send us the restaurant, the page URL and the correct detail through the contact form. We fix facts quickly and we say what we changed. No charge, no account required, no queue you can pay to skip.

Can I reply to a take about my restaurant?

Yes — in public, underneath it, in your own words, with no time limit and no charge. It's the single most useful thing an owner can do here. The replies that land are short and unglamorous: thank the person, say what changed, invite them back.

Can I pay to rank higher?

No. Promoted placements never appear inside rankings — rankings stay ranked. Every ad is labeled as an ad, there is no native, no partner write-up, no wink. Spend cannot change a score, delay a score, soften a score, or trigger a visit.

So what can I actually buy?

Reach for a badge you already earned. A place ranked 50 or higher can pay to show that badge off to more people. A place that hasn't been ranked yet has nothing to buy, and nobody to call about it. Eligibility is computed from the score and never negotiated.

↑ Back to top

Section 8 of 13

Your account

Free to join, free to leave, and nothing clever happening in the background.

Is an account free?

Free to join and free forever. There is no paid tier for readers and no plan to build one — advertising is how this gets paid for.

Do I need one just to browse?

No. Every listing, every ranking and every write-up is readable signed out. An account is for the things that put your name on something: writing a take, voting on whether you'd go back, saving places, adding photos, and adding a restaurant.

What does an account get me?

A public profile that's yours to dress — photo, background (pick a house one or upload your own), a bio, your socials — with your takes on it. Two saved lists, Want to Try and Been There (writing a take marks Been There for you automatically), a vote on every listing, and your standing with the Tasters, which climbs on track record rather than volume. Your account page has all of it.

What name shows on my takes?

Your display name, on a public profile at your own username. Not "a verified diner", not a number. One account per person, under the name you go by.

How do I delete my account?

Yourself, in settings — no email, no waiting on a person. Type your username to confirm, and everything goes: profile, takes, votes, saved lists, photos, email address. It's immediate and it isn't reversible. What we collect, in full →

↑ Back to top

Section 9 of 13

Corrections & removals

Facts go stale, kitchens change hands, and sometimes we're wrong. Here is what we'll fix and what we won't.

Something on a listing is wrong, or the place has closed.

Tell us and we'll fix it. Bring the restaurant, the page URL and the exact detail, plus anything that shows it — a receipt, a menu, a timestamp. Send a correction. We publish corrections with the same enthusiasm we publish everything else.

Will you remove a take because a restaurant asks?

Only if it breaks a rule on the house rules page — a meal nobody ate, a conflict of interest, personal information about staff, threats, spam. We don't remove an honest first-hand account because somebody would rather it wasn't there. If you believe something in a take is factually false — not unflattering, false — write to us with the exact claim and whatever shows it, and we'll investigate properly and tell you what we found either way.

How do I report a take?

Anyone signed in can report anything, including an owner reporting a take about their own restaurant. Pick a reason, and a person reads it, not a scoring model. Volume never decides the outcome — if it did, the loudest party would always win.

Can anyone pay to make a take disappear?

No. Not advertising spend, not a sponsorship, not a partnership. There is no internal process for paid removal, because we never built the product. The flip side is just as flat: rule-breaking takes come down for free, for everyone, whether or not the restaurant has ever given us a dollar.

You caught a place on a genuinely unusual night.

Say so, with specifics — dates, dishes, what changed — and we'll go back. One fresh anonymous visit, on our dime, by someone who hasn't read the first write-up. Ask for another look.

↑ Back to top

Section 10 of 13

Why ratings and reviews stopped working

Nobody involved is being dishonest. Two systems that used to help just stopped separating anything — and that is the whole reason this site has its own number.

What is actually wrong with star ratings?

They only use about a tenth of themselves. Ratings for real, operating restaurants sit almost entirely between 4.0 and 4.7 — a scale that runs one to five and in practice moves through half a star. Two things push it there. People mostly rate places they already chose, so the sample is friendly before anyone eats. And a five-point scale collapses under politeness: most people give five unless something actually went wrong. So a 4.5 tells you very little, because nearly everything is a 4.5.

And what is wrong with the reviews underneath?

People write when something was remarkable — wonderful or infuriating. The ordinary good meal, which is most meals, almost never gets written up, so the pile is the two ends of the experience and very little of the middle. A lot of it is not about the food either: a slow driver, a full car park, a wrong order on a Saturday. All real, and none of it tells you whether the kitchen is good on a Tuesday. And nobody reads four hundred of them, so the number ends up doing all the work anyway.

Is a 4.6 from nine people the same as a 4.6 from nine thousand?

No, and that is one of the quietest problems with the old way — both are printed identically. Here, weight of evidence is part of the arithmetic: a high score from a handful of ratings is pulled toward the middle until enough people have weighed in, and nothing is ranked at all under 25 ratings.

So what does the Sweet Score ask instead?

Not how many stars, but where a place sits against everything else of its kind, near you. That turns a squashed half-star band into a full 4-to-96 scale where the gaps mean something — a bagel shop measured against bagel shops, in its own county. The whole method is public, down to the arithmetic.

↑ Back to top

Section 11 of 13

The numbers page

Everything the board knows about itself, published rather than summarised. Every figure on it opens the list behind it.

What is on the numbers page?

The numbers page is the whole board counted: how the scores are distributed against how star averages are distributed, the dishes reviewers name most, what each category is worth, whether spending more actually buys a better meal, the densest places to eat, and the blocks that turn out to be disproportionately one thing. Every figure is a link — a stat you can't walk into is trivia.

What is the one number that explains this whole site?

78% of the places we track land between 4.0 and 4.7 stars. That is the entire reason the Sweet Score exists: a badge that nearly everybody wears is not information, it is decoration. The two charts at the top of the numbers page show the same restaurants under both systems — one is a spike, the other is a spread.

What does "9.8x more steakhouse" mean?

It is arithmetic, not folklore. For every neighbourhood we work out what share of its restaurants belong to a category, then compare that to the same category's share of the whole region. Koreatown comes back 46x Korean. Brighton Beach, 57x Eastern European. City Island, 11.5x seafood. Most towns come back with nothing at all — which is the honest answer for a street that just has some of everything. Every block with a specialty.

Is there a numbers page for my town?

For the bigger ones, yes — every county has one, and so does any town with at least 100 listings. Smaller towns get the same measurements on their own town page instead of a thin page of their own. Start at the town directory and follow the 'by the numbers' link.

How current is any of this?

Rebuilt nightly from the live board. Nothing on that page is typed by hand, which is also why we can publish it: there is no version of these figures that we get to shade.

↑ Back to top

Section 12 of 13

Being part of it

The scale is finished. What it needs is people who go — and there is a board that tracks who does.

What does being a Taster get me?

A byline, a public profile people can follow, and the only kind of influence on this site that exists: Tasters' write-ups move a score. You go unannounced, you pay your own check, and nothing is comped by the restaurant — which is exactly what makes the take worth reading. What a Taster does.

What is the leaderboard?

The leaderboard ranks the people, not the restaurants. Takes written, photos added, helpful votes earned — it is public and it moves. Being the person who wrote the definitive line about a place is a real thing to be, and this is where it shows.

I'm not a Taster. Can I still do anything?

You are most of what makes this work. Add a place that is missing, put up a photo taken by somebody holding a fork rather than a PR agency, write a take, vote on whether you'd go back. All of it counts toward the board, and photos and takes are the two things this site cannot generate for itself.

Why does sharing matter so much to you?

Because a link on its own is a dead paste. Every listing, ranking, dish and neighbourhood here has a share button that sends the number with it — and a number settles an argument that a link cannot. That is genuinely how the good places get found. The most forwardable facts are on the numbers page.

Is any of it paid?

No, in both directions. Joining is free forever, there is no paid tier for readers, and Tasters are not paid for takes — you write up meals you were going to eat anyway, on your own dime, which is the only reason the write-up is worth anything. Nobody can pay to raise a score either. If money could reach the number, the number would be worthless, and then so would the site.

↑ Back to top

Section 13 of 13

About Sour Grapes

The short answers to the questions people open the About page for.

Why is it called Sour Grapes?

Sorting the sweet from the sour is the whole job. We just never show you the sour part. The name is a joke about the sorting, not about anybody's cooking.

Who runs it?

Sour Grapes was founded by Michael Szerencsy, who lives here, eats here, and got tired of losing track of the places he recommends. It's a small operation, and that's a feature: there's no sales team, so nobody's bonus depends on where a place lands.

How do you make money?

Advertising, and we'd rather say so than pretend otherwise. It pays for the meals we buy. Every placement is labeled, none of them appear in rankings, and none of them can reach a score.

Do you ever publish a negative review?

Never. Clear 50 and you get a number, a badge and a spot in the rankings. Below it you get a full, useful listing and no adjective at all. There is no bottom of the list here because we don't publish one — a discovery site is for pointing at the good ones, not for grading everybody.

Where do I read the full method, or get in touch?

How ranking works has the whole method down to the arithmetic. About is why any of it exists, the house rules cover what stays up and what comes down, and contact reaches an actual person.

↑ Back to top

Still stuck?

If the answer isn’t up there, write to us — a person reads it, and if enough people ask the same thing it ends up on this page.

Ask usRead the method

Scores can't be bought. Only earned. Every number on this page comes out of the same code that publishes the scores — see how ranking works.