Volume counts
A rating with barely any evidence behind it does not get treated like one with thousands. Confidence has to be earned before it counts for anything — which is also what protects a brand-new place from a couple of quiet nights.
Every score here is a rating built from a position: where a place sits against every other place in its county. That is what makes two listings comparable, and it is what lets a badge mean something specific instead of something nice.
The bar. At 50 a place is better regarded than half of its own county — so that is where a rank, a badge and a number switch on. Below it we publish the facts and skip the grade.
The Sweet Score, then the Tasters, then the share who’d go back. Same order on every page, every card, every email — so nothing can be reordered into looking better than it is.
The one headline number: Local favorite 50+ · Top 25% at 78 · Top 10% at 90.
Computed from people who ate there themselves. Nobody hand-picks this number.
One question, open to all members. Not a rating — a recommendation.
The badges: Local favorite 50+ · Top 25% · 78+ · Top 10% · 90+ · 💎 Underrated
A 0–100 position, built from whatever evidence there is. It is ours when we have been ourselves, the tasters’ once enough of them have filed, and otherwise it is built from the ratings the place already carries — weighted for how much of that evidence stands behind it. It renders lavender at 50, chartreuse at 78 and pink at 90, the same way on every surface of this site. What feeds it: the food, the consistency, the service, and what it all cost. What does not feed it: advertising spend, whether the owner emailed us, or how nice the tote bag was.
Computed from verified locals who answered a short list of pointed questions about a meal they ate first-hand. It is always shown in lavender, never colour-coded by badge, because it answers a different question than ours. No single person sets it, and it appears as soon as one take exists — with the number of takes printed beside it, so a score built on one is never dressed up as a score built on twenty. Tasters never see our number before they answer. How the Tasters work →
Not a star rating. One question put to every member: would you go back? The number is the percentage who said yes, always last. One vote per member per place, votes are visible only after you cast yours, and it never feeds the Sweet Score. It is the room’s gut check sitting next to ours.
And that is the whole list. There is no badge for the bottom of the scale, because we do not publish one. A place under 50 gets a full listing — address, hours, cuisine, photos, what tasters said — and no number or badge. We are here to point you at the good ones, not to grade everybody.
Five stars is a short ruler.
The Sweet Score takes that same praise and lays it out on a scale with room in it, so the difference between good and great is visible again.
A rating with barely any evidence behind it does not get treated like one with thousands. Confidence has to be earned before it counts for anything — which is also what protects a brand-new place from a couple of quiet nights.
Ratings run hot in some categories and cool in others. A place is measured against the ones it competes with, so a great pizzeria is not penalised for keeping good company.
The exact weighting stays private. Where a score leans on the ratings a place already carries, a public formula would be an instruction manual for inflating one. Everything we control — the visit, the receipt, the questions the tasters answer — is spelled out on this page.
A listing that hasn’t cleared the bar shows the useful stuff — where it is, when it’s open, what it serves, photos, and whatever the tasters have added — and the words Not ranked yet. We never print a placeholder score, a “3.5 by default,” or an average of its neighbours — nothing that reads as a grade. Where a place has fewer than 25 ratings and nobody has been yet, we don’t place it at all: too thin to be fair either way.
Most places on this site are scored without anyone from here setting foot in them — there are tens of thousands, and pretending otherwise would be the first lie. But every first-hand visit that does happen follows the same rule. Book under a name nobody there knows, sit where you’re put, wait like everyone else, pay the full check. No comped meals, no press dinners, no heads-up call.
Every ranked place goes back into the rotation on a fixed schedule — the same schedule for the ones we loved and the ones paying us for a banner. Chefs change, kitchens find their feet, standards move. A score is a snapshot with a date on it, and the date is printed.
Facts go stale — hours change, chefs move, a place renovates. If something on a listing is wrong, or you think we caught a place on a genuinely unusual night, say so and we’ll go back. One fresh anonymous visit, by someone who hasn’t read the first write-up.
Scores can't be bought. Only earned.
Who the tasters are, what gets a take pulled, and what it costs to be seen here.
Something here look wrong? Tell us — we publish corrections with the same enthusiasm we publish everything else.