The best seafood
around here.
Ranked by the Score, with the regulars and the would-you-go-back share alongside. Anonymous visits, meals paid for, and every place measured against the same scale.
Nothing here has cleared the bar yet, so this list is ordered by Hype Number — the one figure every place carries from day one. Ranks switch on at 60.
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & BarTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 3,234 ratings behind it.
Little Creek Oyster Farm & MarketTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 512 ratings.
Blue Water FishTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 203 people have found it. Underrated.
Fresh Catch SeafoodTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 124 people have found it. Underrated.
Captain IhabTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 81 people have found it. Underrated.
Voodoo Crab North BabylonTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 447 ratings behind it.
Bell & AnchorTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 296 ratings behind it.
Schultzy's RestaurantTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 255 ratings.
Little FishTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 179 people have found it. Underrated.
Popei's Clam BarTop 25%
Top 25% of everywhere we track, on 2,466 ratings.
Voodoo Crab of CentereachTop 25%
Rated above the Centereach median of 41.
DJ's Clam Shack WantaghTop 25%
Rated above the Wantagh median of 60.
New Wave SeafoodTop 25%
Sits in the upper quarter of everything we cover.
Varney's RestaurantTop 25%
Top 25% of everywhere we track, on 640 ratings.
DJ'S Clam Shack Stony BrookTop 25%
Rates well and only 232 people have found it. Underrated.
Sophie'sTop 25%
Rates well and only 221 people have found it. Underrated.
Northport Fish & LobsterTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 170 people have found it. Underrated.
Captain Bills Restaurant & CateringTop 25%
Sits in the upper quarter of everything we cover.
Red LobsterTop 25%
Top 25% of everywhere we track, on 1,914 ratings.
Jerry & The MermaidTop 25%
Rated above the Riverhead median of 40.
Sexy Crab Cajun Seafood, Sushi & Bar-All You Can Eat - LevittownTop 25%
Top 25% of everywhere we track, on 1,126 ratings.
Bostwick's on the HarborTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 144 people have found it. Underrated.
Old Bait ShopTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 43 people have found it. Underrated.
Voodoo Crab of MassapequaLocal favorite
Well thought of in Massapequa — 1,047 ratings.
Know somewhere we’re missing?
Put it on the map. The most-requested places go to the front of the queue — anonymous visit, on our dime.
Rankings order by the Score; ties break by the regulars’ score. Promoted placements never appear in rankings — they’re labeled and live elsewhere. How ranking works →