The best pizza
around here.
Ranked by the Score, with the regulars and the would-you-go-back share alongside. Anonymous visits, meals paid for, and every place measured against the same scale.
Nothing here has cleared the bar yet, so this list is ordered by Hype Number — the one figure every place carries from day one. Ranks switch on at 60.
The Pizzeria of LindenhurstTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 1,023 ratings.
Via Cuma - Valley Stream - Sourdough Pizza & CucinaTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 501 ratings behind it.
Bravo Pizza (K)Top 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 451 ratings behind it.
Catusco's PizzaTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 243 people have found it. Underrated.
The Pizzeria of Bay ShoreTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 1,055 ratings behind it.
The Pizzeria of BabylonTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 1,352 ratings.
Eddie D'sTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 336 ratings behind it.
Red VolpeTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 379 ratings.
Vincent’s NYWF PizzaTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 148 people have found it. Underrated.
Alessia's Pizza & Pasta (formerly Caffe Catania)Top 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 99 people have found it. Underrated.
The Pizzeria of YaphankTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 303 ratings behind it.
Le Castella Pizza & PastaTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 164 people have found it. Underrated.
ZestTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 489 ratings behind it.
KC's Pizza and Wings - Islip TerraceTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 315 ratings behind it.
American Pie Pizzeria SouthamptonTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 134 people have found it. Underrated.
Joe's Pizza & PastaTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 2,509 ratings.
Alberts Pizza of MedfordTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 104 people have found it. Underrated.
The Pizzeria of BayportTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 917 ratings.
Alfie's Pizzeria & RestaurantTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 961 ratings.
Saverio's Authentic Pizza NapoletanaTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 613 ratings behind it.
Shelter Island SliceTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 153 people have found it. Underrated.
Famous Lucas PizzeriaTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 175 people have found it. Underrated.
The Pizzeria of SmithtownTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 574 ratings behind it.
Mary's Pizza and PastaTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 709 ratings behind it.
Know somewhere we’re missing?
Put it on the map. The most-requested places go to the front of the queue — anonymous visit, on our dime.
Rankings order by the Score; ties break by the regulars’ score. Promoted placements never appear in rankings — they’re labeled and live elsewhere. How ranking works →