Pressing the grapes…
🍴 Dish · Frozen Custard · ManhattanBest places for
Best places for
frozen custard in Manhattan, NY.
Pizza Plus in Financial District tops the list. Every place in Manhattan, NY where reviewers actually named the frozen custard, best first.
1Rank
Pizza PlusTop 25%
Financial District · Pizza · $
Upper quarter of New York County — 278 ratings behind it.
83Sweet Score278 ratings
2Rank
Shake Shack Madison Square ParkLocal favorite
Gramercy · Burgers · $
Rated above the typical place in New York County.
76Sweet Score7,818 ratings
3Rank
Shake Shack Theater DistrictLocal favorite
Times Square · Burgers · $
Rated above the typical place in New York County.
62Sweet Score15,173 ratings
4Rank
Shake Shack Herald SquareLocal favorite
Garment District · Burgers · $
Rated above the typical place in New York County.
62Sweet Score11,636 ratings
5Rank
Shake Shack Midtown EastLocal favorite
Murray Hill · Burgers · $
Rated above the typical place in New York County.
61Sweet Score4,043 ratings
6Rank
Shake Shack West VillageLocal favorite
West Village · Burgers · $$
Rated above the typical place in New York County.
59Sweet Score1,942 ratings
—
Shake Shack Bryant Park
Times Square · Burgers · $
—No score yet1,475 ratings
—
Shake Shack Astor Place
East Village · Burgers · $
—No score yet2,310 ratings
—
Shake Shack Battery Park City
Battery Park City · Burgers · $
—No score yet3,783 ratings
—
Shake Shack Upper East Side
Upper East Side · Burgers · $
—No score yet5,194 ratings
—
Shake Shack Meatpacking District
West Village · Burgers · $
—No score yet490 ratings
—
Wild Cherry
West Village · Restaurant · $$$$
—No score yet76 ratings
—
Shake Shack
Chelsea · Burgers · $
—No score yet1,490 ratings
—
Shake Shack Harlem
Harlem · Burgers · $
—No score yet1,771 ratings
—
Shake Shack 1700 Broadway - 53rd & 7th
Hell's Kitchen · Burgers · $
—No score yet2,882 ratings
—
Shake Shack Grand Central Terminal
Midtown East · Burgers · $
—No score yet3,137 ratings
—
Shake Shack
Financial District · Burgers · $
—No score yet5,107 ratings
—
Shake Shack Upper West Side
Upper West Side · Burgers · $
—No score yet8,562 ratings
—
Shake Shack - Penn Station
New York · Burgers · $
—No score yet286 ratings
—
Shake Shack 630 Lexington Ave - 54th & Lex
Midtown East · Burgers · $
—No score yet1,094 ratings
—
Shake Shack Columbus Circle
Hell's Kitchen · Burgers · $
—No score yet230 ratings
—
Shake Shack Lower East Side
Lower East Side · Burgers · $
—No score yet284 ratings
—
Shake Shack Morningside Heights
Upper West Side · Burgers · $
—No score yet512 ratings
—
Shake Shack
Chelsea · Dessert · $
—No score yet4,397 ratings
That’s all 24 of them ✦