Eating in West Islip
Ranked by the Score, with the regulars, the Hype Number and the would-you-go-back share alongside it. Anything not ranked yet is still listed here with the facts — we just haven't put a number on it.
The Chefs Table Long IslandTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 55 people have found it. Underrated.
1683 Sports Bar & RestaurantTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 98 people have found it. Underrated.
Lion's DenTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 161 people have found it. Underrated.
Brownstones Coffee West IslipTop 25%
Top 25% of everywhere we track, on 1,077 ratings.
Besito Mexican Restaurant - West Islip NYLocal favorite
A local favorite — 1,209 ratings and a good one.
Hometown HeroesLocal favorite
A local favorite — 340 ratings and a good one.
Our Little Italy Pizza & PastaLocal favorite
A local favorite — 534 ratings and a good one.
Farrells of BrooklynLocal favorite
A local favorite — 395 ratings and a good one.
Bella Cucina Pizzeria RestaurantLocal favorite
Well thought of in West Islip — 182 ratings.
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of West Islip
On the map in West Islip. Not ranked yet.
Bang Bang Burritos
On the map in West Islip. Not ranked yet.
Primi Italian Steakhouse
Steakhouse in West Islip · 553 people have rated it.
La Slice Pizzeria
On the map in West Islip. Not ranked yet.
Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta
Pizza in West Islip.
Atlantis Diner
Diner in West Islip · 1,359 people have rated it.
Best Kitchen
Chinese in West Islip · 96 people have rated it.
Long River
On the map in West Islip. Not ranked yet.
Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
Pizza in West Islip · 124 people have rated it.
Four Season Kitchen
On the map in West Islip. Not ranked yet.
Gavone's Pizza
Pizza in West Islip.
Panda Garden Chinese Restaurant
On the map in West Islip. Not ranked yet.
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Dessert in West Islip.
That’s all 22 of them ✦
Something in West Islip we haven’t got to?
Put it on the map. Requests move the queue, and the queue decides where we eat next — anonymously, on our own dime.
Ordered by the Score. Places that haven’t earned a rank are listed, not ranked. Scores can’t be bought. Only earned. How ranking works →