Eating in Shelter Island
Ranked by the Score, with the regulars, the Hype Number and the would-you-go-back share alongside it. Anything not ranked yet is still listed here with the facts — we just haven't put a number on it.
Opties and DinghiesTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 155 people have found it. Underrated.
Shelter Island SliceTop 10%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 153 people have found it. Underrated.
Maria's KitchenTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 223 people have found it. Underrated.
Vine Street CaféTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 249 people have found it. Underrated.
Commander Cody's Fish ShoppeLocal favorite💎 Underrated
Rates well and only 205 people have found it. Underrated.
SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill
On the map in Shelter Island. Not ranked yet.
The Islander
American in Shelter Island.
That’s all 7 of them ✦
Something in Shelter Island we haven’t got to?
Put it on the map. Requests move the queue, and the queue decides where we eat next — anonymously, on our own dime.
Ordered by the Score. Places that haven’t earned a rank are listed, not ranked. Scores can’t be bought. Only earned. How ranking works →