✦ Bay Shore, counted

Bay Shore by the numbers.

Every restaurant we track in Bay Shore, Suffolk — measured on exactly the same scale as every other street in the region, which is the only way these figures mean anything next to anybody else’s.

Median Sweet Scoreacross 166 scored places

The reason this site exists

Star averages can't tell anyone apart

72% of every place we track lands between 4.0 and 4.7 stars. The most common score of all is 4.5 — that badge is worn by 27 different restaurants. A number that everybody has is not information. The Sweet Score spreads the same places across 19 bands instead of one.

Star average — one spike, no separation

Sweet Score — the same places, actually spread out

How the Sweet Score is built →

Where a street has a specialty

The blocks that are actually known for something

Not folklore — arithmetic. For every neighbourhood we ask what share of its restaurants belong to a category, and compare that to the same category’s share of the whole region. Bay Shore is 2.3× more Seafood than the region average. These are the streets you go to on purpose.

Bars are the multiple against the regional average. Every town →

What people actually order

The 16 dishes reviewers name most

Pulled from what reviewers wrote, not from menus. If a dish shows up here it’s because people kept bringing it up unprompted — which is the only kind of recommendation worth anything.

All the dishes →

The question everybody asks

Does spending more get you a better meal?

A little, and then it stops. The median $ place scores 46; the median $$$$ place scores 77. Four dollar signs buys you 31 points — on a scale where the gap between #1 and #50 in a single town is bigger than that.

Price	Places	Median Sweet Score	Median ratings
$	72	46	200
$$	73	52	372
$$$	6	56	956
$$$$	1	77	1,617

The categories

What this region is made of

Every place belongs to every category it earned, so these add up to more than 184. The median column is the honest one — a category with a lot of places and a low median is a category where picking badly is easy.

Category	Places	Median score	Ratings behind it
Deli	31	46	6,248
Coffee	21	34	8,015
Pizza	20	50	6,687
American	18	39	13,959
Bar & Grill	16	72	5,174
Bakery	15	43	3,413
Dessert	14	29	3,483
Seafood	14	32	13,120
Breakfast & Brunch	13	46	10,702
Mexican	13	52	8,633
Latin	11	29	4,205
Chinese	10	50	3,128
Fast Food	10	26	6,188
Italian	9	48	5,204
Japanese	7	42	3,809
Burgers	6	64	6,383
Asian	5	45	1,323
Sushi	4	35	1,871

Every ranking →

The list nobody else can build

Loved, and almost nobody knows

High Sweet Score, barely any ratings. These are the places where the people who have been are near-unanimous and the crowd hasn’t arrived. This is what a percentile can find and a star average can’t.

The other end

The most-rated restaurants in the region

Volume, not quality — though the two turn out to be less related than anyone expects. These are the places everybody has an opinion about.

What the board can do for you

Counted, so you can filter by it

Every one of these is a list. Outdoor seating in August, somewhere that takes a reservation, somewhere that will let the dog sit down too.

Every filter →