The Eccentric Bagel
Ranked from the ratings we track · nobody has written it up yet
#3 of 12 in Shelter Island: The Eccentric Bagel, a Bagels place in Shelter Island. It turns up in our Coffee and Deli lists too. The cream cheese is what comes up. Reviewers keep mentioning that there are gluten-free options. Practically: it opens for breakfast and does takeout. Its Sweet Score of 88 rests on 121 ratings. Expect $ prices.
How it stacks up
Every place is measured the same way, so these are real positions in a real line — not a grade out of a hundred. The Eccentric Bagel sits in the top 1% of bagels places we track.
Three more worth the drive
Other bagels spots near Shelter Island that have earned a score, best first.
What people talk about
Pulled from what reviewers actually wrote about The Eccentric Bagel — the dishes they named and the things they kept coming back to.
- Total spent: not yet
- Longest wait: not yet
- Appeal status: none filed 👀
- 25 W Neck Rd #1, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
- Shelter Island, NY · Suffolk County
- Get directions ↗
When the door is open
| Monday | 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM |
| Thursday | 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM |
| Friday | 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM |
| Saturday | 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM |
| Sunday | 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM |
What it actually looks like
Shot by members, on phones, at the table. Nothing here came from a press kit.
No pictures of this place yet
Every photo on this site was taken by somebody holding a fork. If you’ve eaten at The Eccentric Bagel, you’ve got the first one on your phone right now — the plate, the room, the parking lot, the sign. Put it up.
Photos of The Eccentric Bagel come from members.
Free account, thirty seconds, no card. Then you can drop pictures straight onto this page.
Sign in to add photosWhat the regulars actually said
Regulars answer ten short questions about a meal they actually ate. Once 3 land, the per-question splits show up here — and so does the regulars’ score.
What people wrote
Nobody has written about this one yet.
Nobody has written up The Eccentric Bagel yet.
The first take on a place gets read the most. Ten short questions about one meal, and you can add photos while you’re there.
Would you go back?
No votes yet. Be the first on the record.
Free account required — one member, one vote. Change it anytime.