sour grapes ✦The best, ranked & rated.
Join free
πŸ“ Suffolk County, NY

The best of Shelter Island, NY

13 places in Shelter Island, ranked on one scale β€” 8 of them have earned a Sweet Score. Opties and Dinghies is first here (94), Shelter Island Slice second (92). This is mostly $ territory (under $15): 44% of the list. The dishes that keep coming up are burger, calamari and lobster roll.

13 places Β· 8 ranked Β· 5 not ranked yet

Sort
Filter
13 places
1Rank

Opties and DinghiesTop 10%

Shelter Island Β· Chinese Β· $ Β· under $15/person
Known fordumplings Β· gelato Β· fried rice#1 in Shelter Island

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 155 ratings.

94Sweet Score155 ratings
2Rank

Shelter Island SliceTop 10%

Shelter Island Β· Pizza Β· $ Β· under $15/person

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 153 ratings.

92Sweet Score153 ratings
3Rank

The Eccentric BagelTop 10%

Shelter Island Β· Bagels Β· $ Β· under $15/person

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 121 ratings.

91Sweet Score121 ratings
4Rank

Maria's KitchenTop 25%

Shelter Island Β· American Β· $ Β· under $15/person
Known forburrito Β· nachos Β· flan

Upper quarter of Suffolk County β€” 223 ratings behind it.

88Sweet Score223 ratings
5Rank

Vine Street CafΓ©Top 25%

Shelter Island Β· American Β· $$$$ Β· $60+/person
Known forcalamari

Upper quarter of Suffolk County β€” 249 ratings behind it.

81Sweet Score249 ratings
6Rank

Commander Cody's Fish ShoppeLocal favorite

Shelter Island Β· Seafood
Known forcrab cakes Β· fried chicken

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

68Sweet Score205 ratings
7Rank

Tuck ShopLocal favorite

Shelter Island Β· Dessert

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

64Sweet Score98 ratings
8Rank

Kyle'sLocal favorite

Shelter Island Β· Bakery Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known foreggs benedict Β· donuts

Rated above the typical place in Suffolk County.

57Sweet Score40 ratings
β€”

The Islander

Shelter Island Β· American Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forhummus Β· home fries Β· nachos

β€”No score yet260 ratings
β€”

SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill

Shelter Island Β· Bar & Grill Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forclam chowder Β· oysters Β· lobster roll

β€”No score yet490 ratings
β€”

Marie Eiffel Market

Shelter Island Β· Restaurant Β· $$ Β· $15–30/person
Known forfrench toast

β€”No score yet288 ratings
β€”

IGA Deli

Shelter Island Β· Deli

β€”No score yet13 ratings
β€”

The Terrace at The Pridwin

Shelter Island Β· Restaurant
Known forchicken sandwich Β· lobster roll Β· ceviche

β€”No score yet8 ratings

That’s all 13 of them ✦

Straight answers πŸ’¬

Eating in Shelter Island, briefly

What is the best restaurant in Shelter Island?

Opties and Dinghies currently ranks first with a Sweet Score of 94, built on 155 ratings. The list re-sorts itself as ratings move, so first place is not permanent.

How many places are there in Shelter Island?

We track 13. 8 of them have earned a Sweet Score, which means they rated above the median for their county and category. The rest are listed with their address, hours and what people order β€” just without a number.

How much does eating out cost in Shelter Island?

The commonest price band on this list is $ β€” under $15 β€” covering 44% of the places we track here.

How is this list ordered?

By the Sweet Score, a 4–96 rating built from where a place ranks against others in its own county and its own category. 50 is the median, 78 is the top quarter, 90 is the top 10%. A place below the median is still listed β€” it just doesn't carry a number, because we only publish a score when it's good news.

Something in Shelter Island we haven’t got to?

Add it and it goes up with its address, hours and what people order. A Sweet Score follows once there is enough behind it to be fair.

Add a place

Ordered by the Sweet Score. Places that haven’t earned a rank are listed, not ranked. Scores can’t be bought. Only earned. How ranking works β†’