sour grapes ✦The best, ranked & rated.

Ranked from the ratings we track · nobody has written it up — be the first ↓

Athens Diner sits in Middle Island. Diner is the category. The gyro, french fries and french toast are what people actually name. Reviewers keep mentioning that the portions are big, the service is quick and parking isn't a fight. It takes reservations, opens for breakfast and has a kids' menu. 313 ratings sit behind it. It's rated like a top-quarter place but reaches a fraction of the audience its peers do. $ (under $15 a head) — for what it's worth.

Where
  • 837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953, USA
  • Middle Island, NY · Suffolk
  • Get directions ↗
⏰ Hours
Mon–Fri 9:00 AM – 8:00 PMSat 8:00 AM – 8:00 PMSun 8:00 AM – 3:00 PM

🏪 Own this place? Claim your listing

Your turnEarn points

Would you go back to Athens Diner?

Nobody has answered yet. You’d be first on the board for this one.

Points put you on the Tasters leaderboard

Found this useful? Send it to whoever always asks where to eat.

Underrated
💎

Rated in the top quarter, but only 313 people have found it — about a quarter of what a typical diner place near here gets.

Where it ranks 📐

How it stacks up

Every place is measured the same way, so these are real positions in a real line — a rating built from where it stands. Athens Diner sits in the top 12% of diners we track.

What comes up 💬

What people talk about

Pulled from what reviewers wrote about Athens Diner — the dishes they named and the things they kept coming back to.

🍇 The Tasters’ Takes

What people wrote

Nobody has written about this one yet.

🍇 The Tasters’ Scorecard

How the tasters scored it

Tasters answer a short list of questions about a meal they ate first-hand. Everything here — the per-criterion answers and the tasters’ score for the listing — appears from the very first take, and the page always says how many it stands on.

The pictures 📸

What it looks like

Shot by Tasters, on phones, at the table — photos and video both. Nothing here came from a press kit, and every frame carries the name of whoever took it.

Add a shot

Photos of Athens Diner come from members.

Free account, thirty seconds, no card. Then you can drop pictures straight onto this page.

Sign in to add photos
Be the first

Nobody has written up Athens Diner yet.

The first take on a place gets read the most. A few short questions about one meal, and you can add photos while you’re there.