sour grapes ✦The best, ranked & rated.
🏆 Best Italian · Long Island

The best Italian places
in Long Island, NY.

650 Italian places in Long Island, NY, ranked on one scale — 374 of them have earned a Sweet Score. Mary's Pizza and Pasta and The Pizzeria of Smithtown are level at the top on 92. 45 of them clear 90, which is the top 10% of the county. Expect $$, $15–30 — that covers 55% of the places here.

374 scored · 650 on the map · 276 listed without a score

EverywhereLong IslandNassauSuffolkQueensBrooklynManhattanThe BronxStaten Island← All categories
Sort
Filter
650 places
25Rank

Mary's Pizza and PastaTop 10%

Speonk · Pizza · $$ · $15–30/person
#1 in Speonk

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 709 ratings.

92Sweet Score709 ratings
26Rank

The Pizzeria of SmithtownTop 10%

Smithtown · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forcacio e pepe · calamari

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 574 ratings.

92Sweet Score574 ratings
27Rank

Toskana Pizzeria RestaurantTop 10%

Westbury · Pizza
Known foreggplant parm · chicken parm · calamari

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 549 ratings.

92Sweet Score549 ratings
28Rank

MaBellaTop 10%

Commack · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forpenne alla vodka · chicken francese · caesar salad

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 413 ratings.

92Sweet Score413 ratings
29Rank

Sempre VivoloTop 10%

Hauppauge · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known fortiramisu · burrata#2 in Hauppauge

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 398 ratings.

92Sweet Score398 ratings
30Rank

Cala Luna RestaurantTop 10%

Mineola · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known fortiramisu · chimichurri · cheesecake

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 167 ratings.

92Sweet Score167 ratings
31Rank

Absolutely Mario - Italian RestaurantTop 10%

Farmingdale · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forcheesecake · rigatoni · calamari

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 737 ratings.

91Sweet Score737 ratings
32Rank

Elisa's RestaurantTop 10%

North Bellmore · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forbolognese · calamari

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 734 ratings.

91Sweet Score734 ratings
33Rank

The Pizzeria of IslipTop 10%

Islip · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forgarlic knots · grandma slice · caesar salad

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 506 ratings.

91Sweet Score506 ratings
34Rank

Dragos PizzaTop 10%

Farmingville · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forgarlic knots

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 425 ratings.

91Sweet Score425 ratings
35Rank

Dough & Co. PizzaTop 10%

Huntington · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forburrata

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 402 ratings.

91Sweet Score402 ratings
36Rank

Nappi's NookTop 10%

Nesconset · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forpancakes · short rib · espresso

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 394 ratings.

91Sweet Score394 ratings
37Rank

Lucia Middle IslandTop 10%

Middle Island · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 371 ratings.

91Sweet Score371 ratings
38Rank

Napoli Pizza & RestaurantTop 10%

Great Neck · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forgarlic knots

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 224 ratings.

91Sweet Score224 ratings
39Rank

Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant SyossetTop 10%

Syosset · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forchicken francese · chicken parm · garlic knots

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 1,597 ratings.

90Sweet Score1,597 ratings
40Rank

Ancona Pizzeria & RestaurantTop 10%

Valley Stream · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forgrandma slice

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 967 ratings.

90Sweet Score967 ratings
41Rank

Pastaru PastificioTop 10%

Mineola · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forbolognese · rigatoni · vodka sauce

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 559 ratings.

90Sweet Score559 ratings
42Rank

Piccolo'sTop 10%

Mineola · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forshrimp scampi · caesar salad · tiramisu

Top 10% in Nassau County, on 367 ratings.

90Sweet Score367 ratings
43Rank

The Bistro PizzeriaTop 10%

Bayport · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forhero

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 336 ratings.

90Sweet Score336 ratings
44Rank

TalinaTop 10%

Babylon · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forgnocchi · espresso

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 207 ratings.

90Sweet Score207 ratings
45Rank

Maroni SoutholdTop 10%Underrated

Southold · Italian · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forchicken parm · linguine#2 in Southold

Top 10% in Suffolk County, on 99 ratings.

90Sweet Score99 ratings
46Rank

Tony's Tacos Floral ParkTop 25%

Floral Park · Mexican · $$ · $15–30/person
Known forquesadilla · churros

Upper quarter of Nassau County — 1,014 ratings behind it.

89Sweet Score1,014 ratings
47Rank

Villa MonteTop 25%

Old Bethpage · Pizza · $ · under $15/person
Known forvodka sauce

Upper quarter of Nassau County — 759 ratings behind it.

89Sweet Score759 ratings
48Rank

Vulcano 081Top 25%

Rockville Centre · Pizza · $$ · $15–30/person

Upper quarter of Nassau County — 599 ratings behind it.

89Sweet Score599 ratings
Straight answers 💬

Italian in Long Island, NY, briefly

What is the best Italian place in Long Island, NY?

Mary's Pizza and Pasta currently ranks first with a Sweet Score of 92, built on 709 ratings. The list re-sorts itself as ratings move, so first place is not permanent.

How many Italian places are there in Long Island, NY?

We track 650. 374 of them have earned a Sweet Score, which means they rated above the median for their county and category. The rest are listed with their address, hours and what people order — just without a number.

How much do Italian places cost in Long Island, NY?

The commonest price band on this list is $$ — $15–30 — covering 55% of the places we track here.

How is this list ordered?

By the Sweet Score, a 4–96 rating built from where a place ranks against others in its own county and its own category. 50 is the median, 78 is the top quarter, 90 is the top 10%. A place below the median is still listed — it just doesn't carry a number, because we only publish a score when it's good news.

Know somewhere we’re missing?

Add it and it goes up with its address, hours and what people order. A Sweet Score follows once there is enough behind it to be fair.

Add a place

Rankings order by the Sweet Score; ties break by the tasters’ score. Promoted placements never appear in rankings — they’re labeled and live elsewhere. How ranking works →