Best places for
key lime pie in Long Island & Queens.
bartaco in Garden City tops the list. Every place in Long Island & Queens where reviewers actually named the key lime pie, ordered by the restaurant’s Sweet Score. To be clear: the number rates the place, not the dish — we can tell you who serves it and who’s well regarded, not which one makes it best.
bartacoTop 10%
Top 10% of everywhere we track, on 927 ratings.
RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarTop 10%
One of the highest-rated places we cover — 1,542 ratings behind it.
Toto'sTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates in the top quarter and only 178 people have found it. Underrated.
CopperhillTop 25%
Sits in the upper quarter of everything we cover.
Millie's Mimosa House & EateryTop 25%💎 Underrated
Rates in the top quarter and only 184 people have found it. Underrated.
Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and BarTop 25%
Top 25% of everywhere we track, on 133 ratings.
Chowder BarLocal favorite
Well thought of in Bay Shore — 512 ratings.
LUNCH Lobster Roll SouthamptonLocal favorite
A local favorite — 511 ratings and a good one.
RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum BarLocal favorite
A local favorite — 1,703 ratings and a good one.
The Frisky OysterLocal favorite
Well thought of in Greenport — 441 ratings.
THE JAMESLocal favorite
Well thought of in Babylon — 440 ratings.
The Ritz CafeLocal favorite
Ahead of the typical american spot around here.
PRIME1024
Steakhouse in Roslyn.
Symi Restaurant
On the map in Northport.
Westlake Fish House
Seafood in Montauk · 281 people have rated it.
The Old Mill Inn
On the map in Mattituck.
The Shipyard Restaurant & Bar
On the map in Greenport.
Alibi Lounge
On the map in Farmingdale.
That’s all 18 of them ✦
Dishes come from what reviewers wrote, matched against a fixed list so nothing is invented. The ranking is of the restaurants, not of the dish itself. How ranking works →